Apagando Ernesto Sabato

Sylvia Colombo

A Argentina foi vanguarda no julgamento dos repressores da ditadura dos anos 70 e por isso merece ser amplamente aplaudida. Assim que o regime militar terminou, em 1983, começaram as movimentações que levaram ao tribunal as juntas responsáveis pela repressão, tortura e morte de cerca de 30 mil pessoas, segundo estimativas de entidades de direitos humanos.

Hoje, já foram realizados mais de 700 julgamentos e estão presos os mais importantes personagens relacionados ao caso. O principal exemplo é o do general Jorge Rafael Videla, que aos 86 anos cumpre pena de prisão perpétua num cárcere comum.

 

O documento que tornou possível todo esse processo, porém, está no eixo de uma polêmica. Trata-se do relatório “Nunca Mais”, que trazia a lista dos cerca de 8 mil casos de desaparecidos levantados pela Conadep (Comissão Nacional sobre a Desaparição de Pessoas). O prólogo do informe era assinado pelo escritor Ernesto Sabato, morto em 2011. Nele, o autor de “Sobre Heróis e Tumbas” contextualizava a violência do período e defendia a chamada “teoria dos dois demônios”, segundo a qual teria havido uma guerra civil na Argentina. Apareciam como responsáveis pela violência não apenas o Estado repressor, mas também os montoneros e militantes de esquerda que promoveram atos criminosos contra a sociedade.

Essa interpretação não agrada em nada o atual governo. Segundo o relato kirchnerista dos anos 70, a ditadura foi uma guerra entre bons e maus em que as vítimas eram heróis imaculados. Obviamente, tem razão ao reforçar que é muito mais sério e indesculpável que o Estado exerça o terror a partir de seus próprios meios e mobilize as Forças Armadas contra a população. Trata-se de um crime injustificado e que atenta contra a humanidade. Por outro lado, não parece correto omitir que os montoneros não eram violentos. A Argentina da época do golpe era conturbada, com bombas e tiroteios provocados pela guerrilha que resultaram, entre outras coisas, em mortes de civis.

Pois a Secretaria de Direitos Humanos tem uma visão parcial do que ocorreu, e divulga certa narrativa da história de forma a reforçar os horrores do Estado e esconder os crimes da guerrilha. Para o governo, a “teoria dos dois demônios” não é conveniente. Os kirchneristas gostam de referir-se aos derrotados dos anos 70 como heróis dos quais eles são agora os herdeiros diretos. Por tanto esses heróis devem ser retratados de forma romântica e positiva.

A primeira tentativa de apagar Sábato e sua interpretação dos fatos se deu em 2006, quando saiu uma nova edição do “Nunca Mais”, com algumas diferenças. Primeiro, a lista de desaparecidos foi aumentada. Não incluia apenas os mortos pela ação direta da repressão como também vítimas de tiroteios e outras situações de violência. É famoso o caso de Alicia Camp, que em 1972 morreu enquanto montava uma bomba que explodiu por acidente. Seu nome foi incluído na lista de vítimas da ditadura. O documento permitiu que mais gente se apresentasse como candidato a receber as altas indenizações distribuídas pelo Estado.

Depois, tratou-se de “esconder” o prólogo de Sábato. Ele seguiu na edição, mas ficou para um segundo plano. O prólogo principal passou a ser um texto da própria Secretaria de Direitos Humanos, com uma interpretação bastante kirchnerista da violência. Agora, sai uma nova edição que omite a assinatura de Sábato.

A comunidade de defesa dos direitos humanos e a dos escritores se levantou contra a arbitrariedade. Em um artigo no jornal “La Nación” (“Roubar os Mortos”), Magdalena Ruiz Guiñazú, jornalista e integrante da Conadep revoltou-se, lembrando o ato de coragem que foi assinar o texto: “Suprimir desse processo o nome de Ernesto Sabato é simplesmente roubar-lhe uma tarefa assumida com enorme responsabilidade em anos em que as Forças Armadas tinham ainda um grande poder (recordemos os golpes da Semana Santa, Villa Martelli, La Tablada, etc).”

Já Graciela Fernández Meijide, também integrante da Conadep e que perdeu um filho na repressão, afirmou: “Desconhecer uma pessoa como Sabato, que aguentou pressões, que nos deu coragem, é um absurdo”, diz.

Para o jornalista Ceferino Reato, autor de “Operação Primícia”, o debate é incômodo para os grandes meios, “porque os faz ver que foram omissos e que estavam do lado da ditadura durante o período”. Reato reforça que o governo está sendo bastante pragmático e direto, por um lado, tem a intenção de facilitar o acesso a grandes montos de indenização a mais gente para ampliar o apoio que tem dos setores de direitos humanos, por outro, reforçar a ideia de que são “herdeiros de heróis, que perderam nos anos 70, mas estão ganhando agora”.

A Secretaria de Direitos Humanos tem grandes méritos ao impulsionar a busca pela verdade e pelos julgamentos dos repressores. Porém, sua atuação é parcial e incompleta. Não contempla todas as vítimas da violência de Estado ao, por exemplo, não considerar os crimes da Triple A (força paraestatal comandada pelo peronismo) e ao não ser transparente em sua política de indenizações.

A “teoria dos dois demônios” é incômoda e indigesta, mas foi proposta por um intelectual valente que tinha muita clareza sobre o que estava acontecendo no calor dos acontecimentos, o que não é algo comum. Polêmica, discutível, tudo isso é verdade. Mas apagar Sabato definitivamente não é a saída. Melhor seria submeter suas ideias a uma cobertura e um debate mais crítico, menos ideologizado, mais plural e menos baseado em sentimentos de vingança. A memória argentina, com tudo isso, ganharia muito, e certamente haveria mais paz no ambiente de cisões estabelecido na sociedade hoje.

 

 

 

Comentários

  1. You should be able to build a ruke with regard to Kontiji serves as well as khost on the fire wall. Contemplate relocating get data to several directory, observe document position throughout SBB adjustments, you can then see data together with your press gamer for the reason that driver’s licence will be for this file not SBB, remen=mber to eliminate an original download, This will job My partner and i didn’t want to also receive the application to acquire. Happy I came across below, shalln’t actually use that right now. Dvd videos are generally inexpensive plenty of today and lots of better quality Happy somebody authored about it. The best way to reach Skies would be to report them how to Offcom plus just about every readers who reads this would support Watchdog, sufficient men and women complaining about it can ensure it is newsworthy.

  3. Have you heard connected with anyone that will be incorrectly arrested involving pirating fine art? My very own INTERNET SERVICE PROVIDER uneasy my family; although the evidence he previously suggests incriminated myself. The Internet protocol address they claimed has been acquire basically is probably a school district thirty-five mls northern involving me. Considering that the dvd Now i’m charged connected with pirating has been Harry Potter, that might seem to be one of the most logical spot to try to find the culprit. Definitely not at myself… the 54 year old who all truly won’t similar to Harry Potter a great deal… Can you aid? My partner and i rely on this computer regarding career, to shed the online will be a disaster around me!
    uggs outlet in nj http://danielcdillon.com/ugg-boot-outlet/uggs-outlet-in-nj.html

  4. What sort of critical app work are you looking to do on the tablet you can’t carry out presently? Make sure you remember that if Dorrie Job opportunities released the actual ipad tablet, ?t had been offered being a 3rd podium selection (along with a desktop and laptops). Expecting some sort of product to accomplish SolidWorks style do the job is absolutely not just what the suitable for. For the reason that same problematic vein, what you may consider being non-serious do the job might be other great consumer (think salespeople). It’s facts concerning workflow and finding what works good for you.
    ugg long boots http://djjordan3g.com/uggs-boots-outlet/ugg-long-boots.html

  5. Thank you Donnie! I certainly decide on typically the destinazione information. Well-formed key terms and also descriptions should still be an integral part of virtually any website for your motives a person note, but with luck , folks learn not really focus on them on the shunning connected with various other SEARCH ENGINE OPTIMIZATION changes.
    Louis Vuitton Outlet http://www.intravnews.com/purchase.aspx

  11. Anybody is definitely interested, the article “Mitt Romney’ s Extraordinarily Reckless Penny-Pinching Compulsion” by simply Alex MacGillis at The Fresh Republic site demonstrates the reason why Romney is absolutely accurate never to discharge further taxes and tax returns, less being a comma far more. Just simply make sure to read this the result of mastication and see the time out and about in to the weeds a fervent reportorial trick musician similar to MacGillis will go if provided nothing at all worth addressing as well as attention. This is a must-see involving unnecessary mudslinging with regards to imprecise terms within the taxes computer that will completely influence Mister. MacGillis which Romney is really a AWFUL MALE. d nThe tax returns of an productive entrepreneur, your company come as hardly surprising, are usually tricky matters. To assess these effectively involves the skills of your documentalist and also a taxes legal representative. Merely subsequently, right after carrying out people mind-numbing assignments, could everyone be in a position to distinguish in between precisely what is correct in addition to incorrect, legit in addition to bogus. Mister MacGillis however wants all people to help miss out right to the actual criminal prosecution period no hit that for the punishment cycle. Romney’s affluent. They have used income tax write offs. Sinful? Obviously she has responsible. And MacGillis’ obtained barrows full of incredibly puzzling along with hopelessly specific data to feed the actual obstruction course of the convoluted, thought-deadening, ahem, writing model. and nThe last few a few months have shown above attain connected with cavil how the lawbreaker party normally generally known as the actual Obama to get Chief executive Campaign has adopted LYING DOWN BEING A SLOW TECHNIQUE. Ala Dolomite all their slogan is usually “Just declare this! inches Correctly, the Democrats want almost nothing a lot better than to inveigle their very own media allies into paying another ninety days accomplishing practically nothing but discussing Romney’s income tax series by means of collection (and we all know the fact that media want important tiny interceiding inveigling). And also to in the event we all the folks will definitely rather certainly not, in the case there were favor gouging out there the view when compared with burrowing including termites straight into 4001 web pages involving taxes and tax returns, perceived along with unbiased gurus like the tax wizards Bad guy Blitzer, Erin Burnett, Donald Gregory, typically the aforesaid Mr. MacGillis, in addition to George Stephanopoulos can be depended on to explain to be able to us all the way suspicious in addition to this many advantages! oftentimes the way unlawful often the deduction said on the internet 53 connected with extra schedule J (as changed 1983) most likely will be; not even mentioning that explained credit rating was in infringement associated with Section 200-1g (section 512, subsection LII, section 69) of the Ut income tax computer code, and supporting, about, the bringing of the offender activity against the Governor because they evaded report generation earnings gained via light slavery with abuse with the Promoting Moonshine to be able to Mormons Behave involving 1934, in addition to we have to only reserved the actual several weeks connected with July as well as Oct to really are able to the bottom of the. in nCats can pursue canines in addition to snowfall african american ahead of we ought to ever see a conclusion to the stage show.
    babyliss straightening hair dryer http://savemabley.com/babyliss-pro-perfect-curl/babyliss-straightening-hair-dryer.html

  13. If anyone is usually attracted, the content “Mitt Romney’ t Extraordinarily Dangerous Penny-Pinching Compulsion” by Alex MacGillis with the Completely new Republic website illustrates why Romney is absolutely right to not discharge any additional tax statements, not so much like a comma much more. Only read this crap and see how long out and about into the weeds an infatuated reportorial minus performer just like MacGillis should go when given nothing at all of importance or attention. It is just a masterpiece involving unnecessary mudslinging regarding unknown procedures from the duty codes which certainly tell Mr. MacGillis in which Romney is really a POOR GUY. some remarkable nThe tax statements of an prosperous individual, it will be met with not surprising, are generally complex extramarital affairs. To evaluate these effectively needs the skills of accountant as well as a taxation law firm. Merely in that case, immediately after doing these mind-numbing duties, may well any person be in a position to distinguish between what is correct in addition to poor, genuine in addition to illegitimate. Mister MacGillis however needs anyone for you to miss to certainly often the citation level not any punch which on the penalties phase. Romney’s wealthy. He has employed income tax reductions. Guilty? Naturally he is accountable. In addition to MacGillis’ obtained barrows rich in splendidly puzzling and hopelessly detailed facts to feed often the hurdle span of his or her convoluted, thought-deadening, ahem, writing model. in nThe previous couple of several weeks have demonstrated beyond get to associated with cavil the fact that criminal enterprise otherwise referred to as the Obama intended for Leader Marketing campaign provides followed LAYING AS A SLOW TACTIC. Ala Dolomite their saying is actually “Just point out the idea! very well Consequently, the particular Democrats would love almost nothing superior to to be able to inveigle all their music allies in investing the next 3 months performing nothing at all however discussing Romney’s income taxes line by brand (and we all know that this media want treasured small with respect to inveigling). And to if we people would likely genuinely quite definitely not, if we would favor gouging away our view as compared to digging just like termites in to 4001 webpages connected with taxes and tax returns, perceived in addition to separate gurus much like the taxes wizards Wolf Blitzer, Erin Burnett, Donald Gregory, the particular aforesaid Mr.. MacGillis, and George Stephanopoulos may be counted on to elucidate to us all just how doubtful in addition to our goodness! perhaps exactly how unlawful often the reduction in price said on line 53 associated with extra routine J (as amended 1983) more than likely will be; not even mentioning that claimed consumer credit is at infringement connected with Section 200-1g (section 512, subsection LII, section 69) with the Utah income tax codes, along with assisting, basically, often the delivering of an felony steps up against the Governor since he or she evaded report generation revenue received through whitened captivity within abuse of the Providing Moonshine for you to Mormons Work connected with 1934, and why don’t we only set aside the months connected with Aug along with Sept to really be able to the bottom of this. in nCats will pursuit pets along with snowfall african american prior to we ought to watch an end into the spectacle.

  14. fuhshniZZle The greatest Music Videos Jukebox beta is actually operating a specific beta specialist campaign. Very first 10, 000 beta testers to generate a playlist can immediately end up being improved for their large registration while beta check concludes. fuhshniZZle blends with Youtube . com, msn, Discogs, Fb in addition to The amazon online marketplace APIs to manufacture a seamless incorporated and revolutionary multimedia encounter.
    authentic louis vuitton bag prices http://www.dunedinhschorus.com/Louis-Vuitton-Outlet/authentic-louis-vuitton-bag-prices.html

  17. If anyone is actually serious, this great article “Mitt Romney’ nasiums Strangely Careless Penny-Pinching Compulsion” by Alex MacGillis within the Completely new Republic web site illustrates why Romney is totally correct to not launch deeper taxation assessments, not really much as being a intervalle a lot more. Merely read this crap to see the time available in the weeds a dedicated reportorial minus musician just like MacGillis will go while granted almost nothing worth focusing on or even curiosity. It is a must-see connected with pointless mudslinging about hidden conditions from the taxation code that will certainly tell Mister. MacGillis that Romney is often a AWFUL PERSON. some remarkable nThe taxation statements of your prosperous buyer, your company come as not strange, are generally complicated matters. To assess them appropriately demands the ability of the curator and a tax legal professional. Solely in that case, after performing people mind-numbing responsibilities, may any individual able to to tell apart among what on earth is proper along with poor, legitimate in addition to lacking legitimacy. Mister MacGillis nonetheless wishes everyone to be able to miss out in order to typically the justice stage no strike this on the penalty stage. Romney’s well-off. They have utilized tax write offs. Bad? Naturally he has accountable. And MacGillis’ received barrows rich in wonderfully puzzling and hopelessly specific information to feed often the obstacle course of his convoluted, thought-deadening, ahem, the entire style. and nThe last few several months have demonstrated beyond get to associated with cavil that this offender party usually generally known as the Obama for Chief executive Marketing campaign possesses adopted LAYING AS A PLANNED TECHNIQUE. Ala Coleman their very own motto will be “Just say this! inches Appropriately, the actual Democrats would love absolutely nothing superior to to help inveigle all their press allies into paying your next ninety days carrying out nothing at all nevertheless discussing Romney’s taxes series by simply range (and as well as how the mass media will need important little in the way of inveigling). And also to in case all of us the people would likely really rather not really, in case we would prefer gouging available each of our eye compared to digging including termites in 4001 webpages of taxes and tax returns, perceived and unprejudiced specialists much like the tax wizards Hair Blitzer, Erin Burnett, Jesse Gregory, the actual aforesaid Mister. MacGillis, and also George Stephanopoulos could be counted on to explain to be able to all of us exactly how suspect and also the many advantages! possibly precisely how illegitimate typically the reduction reported on-line 53 regarding supplement routine M (as modified 1983) very likely is definitely; also said credit score was in breach involving Section 200-1g (section 512, subsection LII, passage 69) with the Ut taxes code, as well as aiding, pretty much, the taking of the felony steps resistant to the Governor since he evaded reporting profits received coming from bright slavery with infringement on the Promoting Moonshine to help Mormons Behave associated with 1934, as well as we have to simply put aside typically the several months connected with June and also September to really are able to the bottom of these. some remarkable nCats will follow pups along with snow black color previous to we ought to ever see an end towards the spectacle.
    ralph lauren outlet 51 military base http://ckholland.com/ralph-lauren-outlet/ralph-lauren-outlet-51-military-base.html

  28. Hi this is a excellent write-up. I’m going to email this to my buddies. I came on this while exploring on google I’ll be sure to come back. thanks for sharing.

Comments are closed.